Watershed 1967: India's Forgotten Victory over China by Probal Dasgupta was a fascinating read. I picked it up after listening to his conversation with Amit Varma on The Seen and the Unseen. He is an engaging storyteller, and the book reads almost like fiction. It opens with spies meeting in Jeddah in 1967, with espionage, international intrigue and echoes of the Great Game, set in the post-war world of the 1960s.
What I found particularly interesting was Major General Sagat Singh and the Indian Army's confrontation with the Chinese at Nathu La and Cho La in 1967.
India was still under the shadow of the humiliating defeat of 1962. Yet here was a General willing to go against orders, challenge the hierarchy and make decisions with enormous consequences. And soldiers who fought and held their ground. A remarkable story of courage and initiative.
The book makes the case that 1967 changed India's military relationship with China. The Chinese were pushed back, perhaps changing perceptions on both sides of India's willingness to defend its borders.
But I've always looked at India-China relations a little differently.
Years ago, I read Rajiv Sikri's Challenge and Strategy: Rethinking India's Foreign Policy, and one thought stayed with me: India and China need not be natural adversaries. The Himalayas themselves create an enormous separation between the two civilisations.
I've also wondered about the historical memory of British imperialism, especially opium grown in India and exported to China.
Tintin's The Blue Lotus introduced me to that ugly chapter. Did India's role within the British imperial system influence Chinese perceptions of India? Or am I making too much of that connection?
The role of Sikkim's royalty, American influence and military leadership in this intrigue was another fascinating part of the book. Straight out of a James Bond or Nick Carter international espionage story!

No comments:
Post a Comment